Subscribe by RSSSubscribe via emailTDF on Google +TDF on FacebookTDF on TwitterTDF on InstagramTDF on PinterestHTML Map
View Full Site
Fancy Supper Onion Pie •The Domestic Front

Fancy Supper Onion Pie 8

I have a lovely and patient husband, who, although he is wise beyond his years, sometimes gets some funny ideas. One of these is that I only like “fancy” food. No matter how many times I try to explain to him that just because I don’t consider the dollar menu at McDonald’s to be an adequate option for date night does not mean my tastes are either snobby or highbrow, he does not believe me. In his mind, I’m only willing to eat a certain type of haute cuisine, and the shorthand to describe that cuisine is caramelized onions.

As a result, he teases me mercilessly about caramelized onions. Whenever I criticize a dish, be it Chinese food or burritos, he’ll say, “Oh, not enough caramelized onions for you?” If I ask for suggestions as to what ice cream flavor I should make, he will say (after I’ve shot down vanilla), “How about caramelized onion?” What my lovely and patient husband fails to realize is that caramelized onions aren’t some chichi ingredient you find in restaurants, but a building block of good, homey cooking, from onion soup to hamburgers to this onion pie, originally called supper onion pie, or if you want to be all fancy, tarte tatin aux oignons.

What I love about this is that it’s so satisfying to eat. The sweetness of the onions contrasts nicely with the sharp hit of mustard, and the cheesy crust meets my bread cravings. It’s a great dish for brunch or a homey supper, and the leftovers are terrific for a takealong lunch.

And best of all, it’s very easy to make. The onions are cut into fat eighths (no real chopping required) and cooked low and slow, and the scone dough comes together in a flash. No rolling is necessary – you can just pummel the dough into shape and spread it atop the pan. And if a few onions stick to the pie plate, you can just artfully rearrange them – no one will be any wiser.

I often make this for dinner, and when my darling husband eats it with enthusiasm, I take my turn to tease him mercilessly about caramelized onions and make him eat his words. Literally.

Fancy Supper Onion Pie
Prep time: 
Cook time: 
Total time: 
Serves: 6
For the filling/topping:
  • 4 medium red onions
  • 1 T olive oil
  • 1 T butter
  • salt and pepper to taste
  • ½ -1 tsp herbs de provence
For the scone dough:
  • 6 oz. Cheddar cheese, extra sharp, grated
  • 1⅔ c. flour
  • 1 tsp. baking powder
  • 1 tsp. salt
  • ½ c. milk
  • 3 T butter, melted
  • 1 T Dijon mustard
  • 1 large egg, beaten
  1. Preheat the oven to 400 F. Peel the onions, halve them, then cut each half into quarters. Heat the oil and butter in the pan, then add the onions and cook over medium heat, stirring regularly, for about 30 minutes until they're soft and translucent and starting to brown. Taste the onions, and season with salt and pepper and the herbes the provence. Turn into a pyrex pie plate.
  2. Combine the flour, baking powder and salt with 4 oz. of the cheese in a bowl. In a measuring cup, combine the melted butter, milk and mustard, stir to combine, then beat in the egg. Make a well in the middle of the flour cheese mixture, dump in the liquid mixture, and stir, probably with your hands but a wooden spoon is fine, until the dough is cohesive and pretty sticky.
  3. Sprinkle the remaining 2 oz. cheese over the onions, pat and stretch the dough into a circle roughly the size of the pie plate and lay it atop the cheese and onions. Press and stretch the dough until it covers all the onions, and press the edges for a rough seal.
  4. Bake 15 minutes, then turn the oven temperature down to 350 and bake another 10-15 minutes. The dough should be golden brown and crisp around the edges. Let cool for a minute or two, then turn out onto a plate and cut into wedges.
Approximately from Nigella Lawson's How to Be a Domestic Goddess


8 thoughts on “Fancy Supper Onion Pie

  1. Reply Sara @ Culinerapy Jun 8,2009 7:32 pm

    Well, what do you know. My family has a much beloved onion pie recipe that looks very little like this (ours is smothered in cheese). I LOVE the cheesy scone crust idea.

    And, yeah, I get the same thing from my husband. He married a gal who lives for (and on) chili cheese fries, yet somehow has the misguided idea that I only like my food fancy. Must be a guy thing.

  2. Reply Eléonora Jun 9,2009 12:12 pm

    On your blog all pretty hungry and give it a treat. I love your way of cooking and it makes me feel … bravo

  3. Reply Phoo-D Jun 10,2009 7:36 am

    Oh I LOVE this! It has all my favorite notes of flavor. Can’t wait to give it a try! Have you ever included fresh thyme on top of the onions or played around with balsamic?

  4. Reply Zahavah/Gayle Jun 10,2009 8:59 am

    WOW….it’s like a version of soupe a l’oignon….fabulous! I’ve saved this to favorites and can’t wait to play around with this.

  5. Reply AndreaQ Jun 10,2009 9:18 pm

    Looks wonderful! I’m sure the cheddar, onion and mustard work fabulously together!

  6. Reply Kevin Jun 15,2009 7:49 am

    An onion pie with a cheese crust sounds great!

  7. Reply heather Jul 24,2009 8:53 am

    I’ll try this out on my boyfriend and see what he thinks. Given the rave reviews of your husband, I think we’re good to go!



  8. Reply dm Aug 27,2010 8:37 am

    I’ve made this and it is lovely.

Leave a Reply




Rate this recipe: